Independent Reviews Are Not Just a Check-the-Box Requirement

For many Money Services Businesses (MSBs), the independent review is viewed as another annual compliance requirement to complete, submit to the bank, and move on from until next year.

In reality, the independent review is one of the most important tools available to help identify weaknesses in your compliance program before they become larger problems. 

A completed review alone is not enough. 

What matters is what happens after the review is finished.

Independent testing is one of the pillars of an effective BSA/AML compliance program. Its purpose is not simply to satisfy a requirement. A quality review evaluates the strength of your compliance program, identifies weaknesses or gaps, reviews transaction monitoring procedures, and provides recommendations to improve controls and reduce risk.

A strong independent review gives MSB owners visibility into areas that may need attention before regulators or financial institutions identify them first.

The Most Common Mistake MSBs Make

One of the biggest issues we see is MSBs treating the independent review as a one-time document instead of an operational tool.

In many cases, findings are not addressed, recommendations are delayed, or the same deficiencies continue appearing year after year. This creates a pattern that signals a lack of improvement and a lack of attention to compliance responsibilities.

When the same issues continue repeating, risk increases significantly.

Why Repeated Findings Matter

Repeated deficiencies can eventually lead to increased monitoring requirements, additional compliance costs, regulatory scrutiny, or even fines and penalties. In more serious situations, it can also create risk for the MSB’s banking relationship or licensing status.

In some cases, businesses may be required to undergo additional compliance monitoring by an outside third party until improvements are made.

The goal is not to create an additional burden, but instead to identify and correct issues before they become larger operational or regulatory problems.

Common Areas Where Issues Are Found

Independent reviews frequently identify issues involving:

  • Late or incomplete CTR filings
  • Weak transaction monitoring practices
  • Missing or outdated documentation
  • Gaps in Customer Due Diligence (CDD) procedures
  • Inconsistent internal processes or controls

While some of these may seem minor individually, repeated deficiencies over time can create significant compliance concerns if they are not corrected.

Improvement Matters More Than Perfection

No compliance program is perfect. What matters most is identifying issues, addressing them promptly, and demonstrating improvement over time.

An independent review should show progress year after year. If the same findings continue appearing without corrective action, regulators and financial institutions may view that as a lack of commitment to compliance obligations.

Although the independent review report is a bank-required document, MSBs are required to undergo independent testing because the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) requires every MSB to maintain an effective Anti-Money Laundering (AML) program, and independent testing is one of the core required elements of that program.

Timing and Consistency Matter

While FinCEN requires independent testing to be conducted periodically, Surety Bank’s policy requires independent testing to be completed every 12 months for MSB customers.

Completing reviews consistently and addressing findings in a timely manner helps maintain a stronger and more effective compliance program throughout the year.

Why This Matters

Compliance is not built once a year during an independent testing. It is built through consistent attention to processes, documentation, monitoring, and corrective action throughout the year.

The independent testing is designed to help identify weaknesses before they create larger operational or regulatory problems. Using it properly can help protect your business, your banking relationship, and your long-term success.

EXPLORE BY CATEGORY

Browse by category to find articles and guides on specific topics of interest.

All Category

Business

MSB

General

Need to talk to one of our team members?

CONTACT US

Or give us a call (386) 734-1647

call us

Other Resources

ALL ARTICLES

ALL ARTICLES

linearrow

MSB

Independent Reviews Are Not Just a Check-the-Box Requirement

LEARN MORE

100th Anniversary Stories

When Banking Feels Personal Again: John Simmons & St. Barnabas’ Experience with Surety Bank | Community Profile

LEARN MORE

MSB

What MSB Owners Need to Know About Oversight and Accountability

LEARN MORE

ALL ARTICLES

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Keep up with the latest news, tips and updates from Surety Bank. Don't miss out on essential banking knowledge - subscribe to our newsletter for expert insights directly in your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Surety Bank continually works to provide greater accessibility to all of its products and services. If you have any questions about accessible banking, call us at 386-734-1647

© 2026 Surety Bank